In the current political climate, the United States is wrestling with the implications of the national debt and the uncertainty surrounding the debt ceiling. A centerpiece of this discussion is the potential impact on Social Security—a lifeline for millions of American seniors and disabled individuals. Within this narrative, political tactics have been employed to sway public opinion and push forward certain policy objectives. Figures like Senator Chuck Schumer and Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen have utilized the Washington Monument Ploy to emphasize the potential disruption to Social Security. However, a deeper dive into the legislative framework reveals that the threat to Social Security might not be as immediate or dire as it appears, thanks to the Contract with America Advancement Act of 1996.